Guild kicking

I was wondering if anyone else thought this:


Shoudn't guild members be kicked from the guild while there online so that

1. They know they are being kicked

2, prevents afk kicking

3. you have a chance to convince the officer/leader from kicking you

What if you're kicking someone who hasn't logged in for eight months?

like he said one of good reason to kick someone if for inactivity so...

You can't kick people who aren't active. That way they always have a chance to complain.
If it happened to you anyway, the guild was probably disbanded. That instantly kicks everybody.

no some people take long breaks from guild wars to play other things or not play anything...

Well it would be nice if you would at least know who you got kicked by.
And it sometimes happend for newbies that they leave a guild by an accident. Then, they dont remember theyre guilds name, what do those guys should do if they want to come back?(xcept not doing it in the future)

Get real...

If someone goes inactive for months without warning, they get the boot. If they want back in, they can let you know when they're back. What your saying would basically make it possible for someone to join your guild and then never play again, forever clogging your roster. So yea, like I said, get real.