Thackary

He wont take any of my sweets. I gave him pumpkin pie and a pumkin cookie, but he wont take my bean cakes or creme brulee so i cannot progress. Anyone else have this issue?

Give him another cookie! Some things he simply refuses to accept. It's not a bug. Here's the skinny on it: http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Thack...Scavenger_Hunt

yeah i have cookies, pie, creme brulee, and bean cakes in my inventory and he wont take any of them

i just want to move on with my life

i thought u needed a b.day cupcake for the sweet

after the update you can give him other sweets too. everything i listed up there and a chocolate bunny.

Yes, you need to give him the required "perfect" items to proceed. - For the sweet, that would be a birthday cupcake.

Not any longer, you don't. It's either one perfect, or three not-perfect.

for your information you don't actually have to complete to scavenger hunt to progress in the WiK storyline.

As of the Nov 18th update, you do have to complete it to finish the WiK stuff. (If you haven't already gotten past that point in the storyline, that is. Please refer to the wiki's "War in Kryta/Walkthrough" flow chart for info on this and any other wonderful changes to the progression.)